The Genealogies of Modernity Journal
A Humble Genealogy: On Christian Hermeneutics
A covenantal genealogy is indexed toward a transcendent God, rather than to contingent historical objectives such as those integral to the immanent frame that Enlightenment rationality (mis)identifies as its exclusive and all-encompassing domain.
Thomas Pfau distinguishes different modes of genealogy
Discerning Genealogies: A Response to Thomas Pfau
The theological tradition requires self-critical appropriation, which must be capable of discerning what, having been passed down, is best forgotten and what is best remembered or re-presented for the Body of Christ today.
Antony Sciglitano looks for what truth can be found in genealogical methods
The Forgotten Young Hegelian
In light of Brentano-von Arnim’s recognition by the Young Hegelians and her association with the Silesian Weavers’ Uprising, it is remarkable that her political writing is so rarely considered in work on the development of Communism.
Anna Ezekiel examines the contributions of a neglected Left Hegelian
Creating a Home for Black Catholicism
If Black Catholics—having lived through repeated disappointments and the demoralizing treatment of their ancestors—are exhausted in the fight, now is the perfect time to find new strength and take heed of history as the Church changes all around them.
Nate Tinner-Williams carves out a space for Black Catholicism
From Genealogy to a Hermeneutics of Tradition
The most compelling alternative to the twin perils of genealogy and fideism, radical immanence and radical transcendence, involves a hermeneutics of tradition.
Thomas Pfau develops a Christian Hermeneutics of Tradition
Enchantment Remains: On Baseball and Modernity
The old ways have not died. Enchantment remains. The very soul of baseball seems up for grabs, with mystery, enchantment, and superstition on the one hand, and science, disenchantment, and statistics on the other.
Jeffrey Waldon on Christopher Beha’s The Index of Self-Destructive Acts
The Genealogies of Modernity End of Year Book List
We have asked some of our writers from this past year to select some of their favorite books from 2020. Perhaps some of these books will end up source texts for future genealogists. So, if you are looking for a last-minute gift for your favorite genealogists, or making reading resolutions for 2021, we have you covered!
Nietzsche Was Not a Genealogist
Contrary to Foucault’s account of genealogy, Nietzsche characterizes his enterprise as the discovery of the true (singular) origin of intellectual and cultural phenomena. Genealogy, in his disparaging account, gets it wrong.
Ryan McDermott develops an answer to the question: what is genealogy?
The Woman at the Heart of German Romantic Philosophy
Karoline von Günderrode’s contributions to the history of ideas have been occluded and forgotten. When she wrote, women’s intellectual efforts went unacknowledged, meaning that we may never know the extent of her influence on the people around her.
Anna Ezekial recovers the philosophical insights of Günderrode
Resisting the Modern Desire for Dominance
Fratelli Tutti offers an alternative to such modern forms of domination and points to fraternal service as a way of countering its love of money, the desire that so often presents itself as development.
Trevor Williams reviews Pope Francis’s latest encyclical
Deep in History: On Christian Genealogical Thinking
“To apprehend the point of intersection of the timeless with time is the occupation of the saint.” -T.S. Eliot
A video conversation between Thomas Pfau, Brenna Moore, Cyril O’Regan, and Maria Cecilia Ulrickson
A Lawless Man
Montaigne was charting new, and uniquely modern, territory. We embrace ourselves, as ourselves, and try to learn to be ourselves, rather than striving to become something other.
Erik Dempsey reviews Pierre Manent’s Montaigne: Life Without Law
Aiming for Japan and Getting Heaven Thrown In
In the parallel spiritual journeys of its characters, Endo’s The Samurai reflects a typically postmodern yearning for transcendence and synthesis of values beyond the conflict of cultures.
Katy Carl on Shūsaku Endō’s The Samurai and finding transcendence beyond the postmodern
Cotton Mather and a Medieval American Mythography
By reaching back to Venerable Bede’s description of righteous conquest, Mather casts American origins as something deeply rooted in time and tradition—an inheritance that cannot be revoked.
M. Breann Leake on continuity from Venerable Bede to Cotton Mather
Microbes and the Birth of the Modern Era
Given all the transformations wrought and about to be wrought by COVID-19, we will see much more attention paid to the role of plagues, pandemics, and pestilences in shaping human affairs.
Andrew Latham looks to microbes to explain macro-changes in history.
Symphony of Life: Wilhelm Dilthey’s Philosophy of History
By observing the patterns in history and finding the hidden unity behind them, we can formulate ideals and new futures based on a better understanding of what humanity is.
Henriikka Hannula develops Dilthey’s philosophy for life.
Action Movies and the Ethics of Climate Malthusianism
Three recent action films—Kingsman: Secret Service, Avengers: Infinity War, and Tenet—face down climate change by pointing to a supposedly new threat: a new crop of Malthusians, out to exterminate parts of the human race for the greater good.
Brice Ezell on the persistence of a bad idea.
Hagia Sophia as a Living Event Space
What is remarkable about Hagia Sophia’s transformations is the ways in which it was architecturally transformed in line with the politico-spatial turning points in the region’s history… These architectural changes have the power to reinforce, and even ignite, historical change.
Emre Çetin Gürer maps the space of historical change in the Hagia Sophia